Name: Amelia Savage
Genre: Young Adult, fantasy romance
Title: Sea of Betrayal
Chapter One
“What a horrid smell!” Annabelle’s mother covered her dainty nose with one hand. “I don’t understand how your father tolerates this. And now your brother…”
Annabelle welcomed the ocean air. The breeze whipped her long golden hair, and she struggled to keep the strands from her face. Her leather boots sunk onto the sand as she followed her mother to the public market.
Shouts of merchants unloading their crates muffled her mom’s complaints. Annabelle focused on the sound of the waves crashing against the wooden posts supporting the dock instead. Sweat and damp provided the ideal environment to the all flies gathered around the stalls. The port was busy, like every Friday morning, but unlike her elegant mother, Annabelle’s simple blouse and pants blended in well with the crowd.
“And as if I didn’t have enough on my mind, I must handle what those incapable servants are paid for myself. Let’s get this over with. The wharves are no place for ladies,” her mother continued.
Annabelle rolled her eyes. Her behavior never met her mother’s expectations but they were worse lately. She somehow got the crazy idea that finding her daughter a suitable husband would transform her into someone less wayward. These were her mother’s exact words. Complete nonsense.
Their destination, Mr. Fell’s stall, was the furthest off the market, near his small trawler.
“Twenty crates of oysters? Can’t give you that much, Mrs. Heatley!” The bulky man dropped his bloody knife on the wooden block, eyes as round as those of the dead fishes on his stand.
“Are those oysters not for sale? Or are you keeping them for someone you consider more important? I wonder who might that be?” her mom asked in her usual haughty tone.
Why did she always have to point out her rank?
Beads of sweat formed across the fisherman’s forehead. “I… I’m sorry, but… the hostel… the cook waits for—”
“Mr. Fell…” Annabelle took a step closer to his stall. “We came to you first because you offer high-quality products. We want only the best for Sunday’s banquet and we’ll make sure everyone knows the meal comes from your place. Aren’t you invited?” She lifted a brow to her mother.
She pursed her thin lips and nodded. Annabelle’s mother grabbed the small purse from her velvet mantle and handed it to the fisherman. Problem solved.
Annabelle stared at the sea. A ship appeared in the distance and she smiled. Her father would be back tonight.
“Thief!”
She turned to the sound. Women cried as a stocky hooded man bolted into the crowd. Annabelle dropped her satchel and ran after him.
“Annabelle!”
Ignoring her mother’s scream, she kept running, dodging barrels, boxes, and people staring at her, their eyes wide. The robber was fast, but she was faster. Robberies happened more often in Narrow Bay, Hastenia’s Capital and if the guards weren’t able to do their job, she had to try. She had weaved and dodged through the haphazard stalls a hundred times before chasing her brother. This was not so different.
The thief turned his head and pulled a stack of lobster cages behind him. Annabelle jumped to avoid them. Everyone jerked aside to let her pass.
She got close enough to grab his jacket, making him stumble and fall. Struggling to stand, his eyes widened as if he had just realized who chased him. She punched his snub nose before he had time to react. Her fist hurt but she tried not to let it show, reminding herself to check it later.
“This doesn’t belong to you.” Annabelle yanked the pouch from his hands.
Alerted by the commotion, two officers approached, guns raised. Their green uniforms were pristine, probably because they had been doing nothing all day. A forced smile formed on Annabelle’s face and she bowed before heading back to her mother. Indignation blazed in her eyes.
“Annabelle, you should have let the patrol apprehend him.” Her mother scowled as she examined her daughter’s tan pants, now covered in dirt.
“Mother, if I hadn’t helped, the thief would still be—”
“That is not your problem.”
Annabelle sighed. A heavy silence grew between them as her mother headed back home. The waves splashed bursts of cool water on her heated skin.
“Don’t wait for me, I’ll stick around here a little while longer.” Annabelle looked at her father’s ship again.
She turned her head in the same direction of her daughter’s and as if she understood, she nodded. “Don’t stay too long. You must not be late for your dinner date with Arthur tonight, remember?”
Even if she wanted to forget, her mother was a talking calendar.
Chapter Two
Noah could see the coast. Familiar shapes in the distance slowly turned into hills and houses. They would be home soon. This new promotion was tiring but worth it. He was glad Governor Heatley could count on him and working under his command was a little payback. He never planned to get higher in ranks but if the governor was pleased with his hard work, then Noah was.
“Lieutenant Jensen.” Governor Heatley’s voice was calm but firm.
Crap.
Noah straightened and saluted the country leader. “Sir?”
“In my office. Now.”
By the serious tone he used, it meant nothing good. And Noah who thought times were getting easier. What a fool. He followed Governor Heatley to his quarters, acknowledging the other officers he passed. They seemed relieved they weren’t the ones being summoned.
The governor entered his office, that also served as private cabin, and headed to his big mahogany desk. “Close the door.”
The light coming from the multiple stained glass added warmth to the austere furniture. He did as ordered and straightened even more, making his whole body on edge.
The old man sat and waited for Noah to do the same. “I want to thank you for your loyalty.”
Whoa. This was unexpected.
“It’s an honor to work under your command, Sir. I’m just doing my job. I’m grateful for the new title and responsibilities.”
The governor smiled but it didn’t reach his eyes. “You worked hard and desire to rest, but I need you on my next mission. Trusted circle only…”
“Of course, Sir, anything—”
Governor Heatley raised his hand to stop him. “In South Islands.”
Noah’s heart constricted.
South Islands. The only place the governor forbade him to return after ‘the accident’. And Noah was perfectly fine with this decision. He even forgot this place existed when he buried those terrible memories. He wasn’t ready to travel to his old homeland. Never imagined he would have to go back there somehow.
“I know what you’re thinking,” the governor continued. “But the past is an enemy no one can defeat.”
“Exactly.” Noah’s word came out harsher than he meant. Realizing he tried to argue with one of the most important person in the world, he clenched his fists and sighed. “When do we leave?”
“In four days.”
Why do you want me there? The words stuck in his mouth. Mostly because it was none of his business. This mission might be crucial. Or leading for so long can make you go crazy.
The sway stopped and Noah realized they docked.
“You may leave now, to make a good use of this spare time.”
Noah raised and made the official salute, but Governor Heatley added: “I expect to see you Sunday and don’t worry, a tailored outfit will be delivered to you just in time.”
I super enjoyed reading this. As a reader, you’ve really captured my attention. I want to read on. You’ve done a great job at worldbuilding and showing me Annabelle’s character in the first chapter. You did a great job of building a description of Annabell and her mother in the first few paragraphs.
ReplyDeleteI’d love to see more worldbuilding in the second chapter. I know where he is, and who he is, but since you did such a great job of bringing the world to life in the first chapter that I’d love to see it carry over in the second chapter.
I’m very interested in what happened in Noah’s past! And I’m interested in, if he was banned from the place, why is the mayor sending him back.
A few questions: I was a little confused at what this sentence meant:
“Or leading for so long can make you go crazy.”
These sentences could be rephrased to run a little more smoothly:
“Realizing he tried (was trying) to argue with one of the most important person (people) in the world,”
“The sway stopped and Noah realized they docked.”
“You may leave now, to make a good use of this spare time.” (Maybe cut it into two sentences. “You may leave now. Make good use of the spare time.”)
“Noah raised (his arm?) and made (to salute) the official salute, but (was inturrpted when) Governor Heatley added”
I laughed out loud at the talking calendar bit.
Hi Laura.
DeleteThanks a lot for your thorough and honest feedback. World-building is one of my biggest weakness so I'm glad you pointed out where it lacked. I will revise the sentences you mentioned.
Thanks again :D
Hi, Amelia,
ReplyDeleteThis was so fun to read. Your MC's voice is strong and her interaction with her mother is well-done, believable and natural. Your sense of humor is also evident. Your descriptions of the market make it easy to visualize the action.
Right after Annabelle and her mom interact with the oyster salesman, mom pursed her lips and reached for her purse. Repetitive. Consider a synonym for one of the purses. :)
What happened to the pouch apprehended from the thief? Does Annabelle give it to the officers?
You've peaked my interest about Noah and his past. It's evident that he will be at the Heatley's Sunday banquet, and I'm interested to see what happens.
In describing the governor's office, I believe a word was omitted: "The light coming from the multiple stained glass added warmth to the austere furniture." Multiple stained glass windows?
Consider the governor's statement to Noah: “I know what you’re thinking”.... Could this be possibly be shown instead of told?
Good job on this!
Thanks Julene for catching the missing word. I'll try to improve my balance between show vs tell more. Thanks again for your kind words.
ReplyDeleteHi Amelia,
ReplyDeleteYour writing is smooth and entertaining. You paint a scene with your words, using sounds, smell, sights and such. It's very easy to slip into this painting.
I can't help but wonder if Annabelle and Noah were made for each other and I can imagine them going of on grand adventures out at sea. For some reason, I'm imagining pirates and islands and treasure. I might be totally wrong, of course. I like how you make the reader understand that Annabelle's father is Noah's superior.
I only have a couple of comments.
First, I wonder if this sounds more like YA than middle-grade. How old is Annabelle? It sounds to me like she must be at least sixteen if she can catch a thief and punch him. Not that it bothers me, of course!
Second, it would help if you added some names instead of pronouns here and there.
Example:
- 'She pursed her thin lips and nodded. Annabelle’s mother grabbed' (maybe start with Annabelle's mother in the first phrase, otherwise it sounds like Annabelle has thin lips)
- 'A heavy silence grew between them as her mother headed back home. The waves splashed bursts of cool water on her heated skin.
“Don’t wait for me, I’ll stick around here a little while longer.” Annabelle looked at her father’s ship again.
She turned her head in the same direction of her daughter’s' (double-check this section. It's sometimes hard to tell who's who. When you say 'Annabelle looked at her father's ship again. She turned her head' it sounds like you're still talking about Annabelle)
- 'The governor entered his office, that also served as private cabin, and headed to his big mahogany desk. “Close the door.”
The light coming from the multiple stained glass added warmth to the austere furniture. He did as ordered and straightened even more, making his whole body on edge' ('he did as ordered' sounds like you're talking about the Governor)
That's it! I can smell a salty adventure ahead!
There's a small switch of words here: 'environment to the all flies'
Sorry, I forgot to switch the two last sentences.
DeleteEek, I can't edit my comment, can I? I'm so focused on middle-grade I forgot these submissions are also for YA. Please disregard my comments about Annabelle's age, I totally get the YA vibe of your story. (Now where's my coffee?)
DeleteThank you for the nice feedback. Annabelle's age is mentioned in chapter three. I wondered if it isn't a little late but I can't cram every info into C.1 either. I'll change the pronouns to make it clearer.
DeleteHi Amelia,
ReplyDeleteI'm one of your assigned mentors for the workshop. Thank you for submitting your work and for the opportunity to read it. I hope that my feedback will be of use.
I quite enjoyed reading your pages. You do a good job setting up your two main characters and their respective dilemmas/tensions.
I don't have much to say about the content itself, but I do have some minor suggestions about phrasing and language. I think you could improve the flow of the narrative by smoothing and rephrasing some of the writing. Though, overall, it's good.
Below are my suggestions:
"Her leather boots sunk onto the sand..." - should "onto" be "into"?
"Sweat and damp provided the ideal environment..." - I'd suggest changing "damp" to "humidity" or something else that's a noun.
"...but unlike her elegant mother, Annabelle’s simple blouse and pants blended in well with the crowd." - I'd suggest rephrasing for clarity, e.g. "but unlike her mother's elegant clothing, Annabelle’s simple blouse and pants blended in well with the crowd"
"I must handle what those incapable servants are paid for myself..." - I'd change the order of words for clarity, e.g. "I must handle myself what those incapable servants are paid for."
"Her behavior never met her mother’s expectations but they were worse lately." - not sure if "they" works here. Maybe better: "Her behavior never met her mother’s expectations but lately things have gotten infinitely worse."
"He did as ordered and straightened even more..." - say "Noah" instead of "he" for clarity.
That's it from me for now.
Cheers,
Katya
Thank you for your feedback and suggestions. I'll make these sentences clearer.
DeleteHi Amelia,
ReplyDeleteI really like your characters, they seem like people in whose head I’ll enjoy spending time. Annabelle is to me a very relatable heroine, I love her disdain for dresses, her headlong rush to catch the thief, and the fact she can hold her own against a man.
I also like the subtle connection between the two POV: one chapter ending with Annabelle looking out to the sea and the ship, the other starting with Noah peering back in the same direction. It’s a beautiful device and it works for me.
I read the excerpt twice. The general flow is good, I didn’t feel like the story drags, I only had several moments which caught me up, so maybe go over them again:
Is the horrid smell her mother complains of the ocean air? That seems strange, that anyone can find ocean air horrid. Maybe she means the smell of rotting seaweed or sea gulls or fish or any of the other not so universally pleasant smells of a port area. If so, it’s better to specify. This way you will also include the sense of smell in the description.
Why is there sand on the ground at the market (so deep that Annabelle’s boots sink into it)? Is the market directly on the beach? To place the reader better, can you include a word or a phrase to describe it (not some long description that will slow down the pace, of course).
The way Annabelle solved the argument with Mr. Fell didn’t work for me, I found it unrealistic how quickly, as if by magic, she convinced the guy. She didn’t say anything special, she just mentioned he was invited to the party and it would be good marketing for him, and problem was solved. I didn’t buy that. Why was she so persuasive? Was it her tone, which was not as arrogant as her mother’s? Does she have a more deep connection with the guy, are they friends? Is it her general friendly, relatable appearance? Maybe she helped Mr. Fell in the past, so he owes her a favour? I hope you understand what I mean, just think about this section and try to make it as believable as possible in order to avoid logical questions in the reader and paint a clear picture of the main character.
What kind of guns do the officers have? Just wondered because this is fantasy and I didn’t expect to see guns. If you can, include a word or a phrase to clarify that image.
That’s it, I’m curious what happens to these two characters!
Good luck 😊
Lily
Thank you for your feedback. I'll see what I can do with the merchant scene. It was obvious to me that she wasn't snob like her mother so the merchant preferred dealing with Annabelle instead. I'll work on that.
ReplyDeleteThanks again!
Hi Amelia,
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for sharing your writing with us! (And I'm sorry I'm late with my feedback!)
I really enjoyed reading these pages. Your writing is very good - fluid and descriptive, and I could clearly imagine the scene in the market. I am wondering about the thief, however. The first 5 pages are very valuable real estate! If the thief isn't part of the story, I'd cut that part.
As for the part on the ship, I couldn't imagine that as easily. How big is the boat? Is it rocking in the waves, or is the water still?
As for Noah, what's his age? I'd clarify that, so the readers don't assume it's Annabelle's father. The modern language - crap, whoa, - also surprised me, as it didn't seem to go with the tone of chapter one.
Also, look for words you can cut - such as: and as if she understood, in this paragraph: She turned her head in the same direction of her daughter’s and as if she understood, she nodded. “Don’t stay too long. You must not be late for your dinner date with Arthur tonight, remember?”
Absolutely love this line: Even if she wanted to forget, her mother was a talking calendar.
Good luck revising and I look forward to reading next week!
Best,
Erin, 1st 5 Pages Mentor
Thank you for your feedback. I'll try to work on that!
Delete