Name: Amelia Savage
Genre: Young Adult, fantasy romanceTitle: Sea of Betrayal
Chapter One
“What a horrid smell!” Annabelle’s mother covered her dainty nose with one hand. “I don't understand how your father tolerates this. And now your brother…”
Annabelle welcomed the ocean air. The breeze whipped her long golden hair, and she struggled to keep the strands from her face. Her leather boots sunk into the sand as she followed her mother to the public market. She insisted to take the long detour by the beach, knowing her mother would prefer sand over mud.
Shouts of merchants unloading their crates muffled her mom’s complaints. Annabelle focused on the sound of the waves crashing against the wooden posts supporting the dock instead.
Sweat and dampness provided the ideal environment to all the flies gathered around the stalls. The port was busy, like every Friday morning, but unlike her mother’s elegant clothing, Annabelle’s simple blouse and pants blended in well with the crowd.
“And as if I didn’t have enough on my mind, I must handle myself what those incapable servants are paid for. Let’s get this over with. The wharves are no place for ladies,” her mother
continued in her usual haughty tone.
Annabelle rolled her eyes. Her behavior never met her mother’s expectations but lately, things have gotten infinitely worse. She somehow got the crazy idea that finding her daughter a suitable husband would transform her into someone less wayward. These were her mother’s exact words. Complete nonsense.
“So if you really want me to be the perfect proper lady, it doesn’t serve you well to bring me here with you, Mother,” she snapped.
Annabelle shouldn’t have said this as she preferred being outside rather than home. Especially when her mother was all in her ‘reception prep mode’.
As they headed to the oysters merchant’s stall, her mother added: “I need you here with me because you know how to talk to these people.”
These people were the reason she had food on the table and clothes on her back. Her mother shouldn’t misprize them because they worked to get those things. As First Lady, she should help them and try to find a way to make the community better instead.
Annabelle could have replied but it was no use. A heavy silence grew between them as they walked toward their destination.
“Thief!”
She turned to the sound. Women cried as a stocky hooded man bolted through the crowd. Annabelle dropped her satchel and ran after him.
“Annabelle!”
Ignoring her mother’s scream, she kept running, dodging barrels, boxes, and people staring at her, their eyes wide. The robber was fast, but she was faster. Robberies happened more often in Narrow Bay, Hastenia’s Capital and if the guards weren’t able to do their job she had to try. She had weaved and dodged through the haphazard stalls a hundred times before chasing her brother. This was not so different.
The thief turned his head and pulled a stack of lobster cages behind him. Annabelle jumped to avoid them. Everyone jerked aside to let her pass.
She got close enough to grab his jacket, making him stumble and fall. Struggling to stand, his eyes widened as if he had just realized who had chased him. She punched his snub nose before he had time to react. Her fist hurt but she tried not to let it show, reminding herself to check it later.
“This doesn’t belong to you.” Annabelle yanked the pouch from his hands.
Alerted by the commotion, two officers approached, their pistol raised. Their green uniforms were pristine, probably because they had been doing nothing all day. A forced smile formed on Annabelle's face and she bowed before handing the pouch to them. Then she headed back to her mother.
Indignation blazed in her eyes. “Annabelle, you should have let the patrol apprehend him.” Her mother scowled as she examined Annabelle’s tan pants, now covered in dirt.
“Mother, if I hadn’t helped, the thief would still be—”
“That is not your problem.”
Annabelle sighed, letting the waves splash bursts of cool water on her heated skin. She stared at the sea. A three-masted man-of-war appeared in the distance and all her tension released at once. Her father would be back tonight. He was the only one able to prevent her mother from controlling her life and she hoped to be able to convince him to let her sail away with him.
“Don’t wait for me, I’ll stick around here a little while longer.”
Her mother turned to the sea and nodded. “Don’t stay too long. You must not be late for your dinner date with Arthur tonight, remember?”
Even if she wanted to forget, her mother was a talking calendar.
Chapter Two
Noah could see the coast as he leaned against the guardrail. Familiar shapes in the distance slowly turned into hills and houses. They would arrive soon. This new promotion was tiring but worth it. He never planned to get higher in ranks but if Governor Heatley was pleased with his hard work, then Noah was.
Patches of orange and red stood out among the dense green barrier on the horizon. It meant in a few weeks, they would put the Mystical in drydock. He would miss the gentle rocking of the ship and the sound of the waves splashing against the hull. But storm season awaited. He would rest then.
“Lieutenant Jensen.” Governor Heatley’s voice was calm but firm.
Crap.
Noah straightened and saluted the country leader. “Sir?”
“In my office. Now.”
By the serious tone he used, it meant nothing good. And Noah who thought times were getting easier. What a fool. He followed the governor to his quarters, acknowledging the other officers he passed. They seemed relieved they weren’t the ones being summoned.
The old man entered his office, which also served as a private cabin, and headed to his big mahogany desk. “Close the door.”
The light coming from the multiple stained glasses windows added warmth to the austere furniture. Noah did as ordered and straightened even more, making his whole body on edge. Inhaling the deep scent of salt and wood, he felt at home. He shouldn’t.
To calm his nerves, he looked over the governor’s shoulder, examining the spines on the shelf against the cabin wall. Volumes he had read a dozen times. Noah couldn’t stare at the leader’s eyes. Bright hazel eyes he knew too well as they were the same as Anna.
Governor Heatley sat and waited for Noah to do the same. “I want to thank you for your loyalty.”
This was unexpected.
“It’s an honor to work under your command, Sir. I’m just doing my job. I’m grateful for the new title and responsibilities.”
The governor smiled but it didn’t reach his eyes. “You worked hard and deserve to rest, but I need you on my next mission. Trusted circle only…”
Another trip. Another chance to be out at sea. He couldn’t help but smile at the thought.
“Of course, Sir, anything—”
“In South Islands.”
Noah’s heart constricted.
South Islands. The only place the governor forbade him to return after ‘the accident’. And Noah was perfectly fine with this decision. He even forgot this place existed when he buried those terrible memories. He wasn’t ready to travel to his old homeland. Never imagined he would have to go back there somehow.
Hi Amelia,
ReplyDeleteI enjoyed your previous submission as well as this one.
In this revision, I wonder if you need to reveal the following:
- Annabelle hopes to sail away with her dad next time. (I sensed this already without you needing to say it)
- Noah recognizes Annabelle in the the Governor's eyes. (I kind of liked the anticipation of waiting to find out whether they'll meet or not)
But whether you leave this or not is up to you, of course.
I imagine you had to take everyone's comments into account, however, in this revision I missed the part where Annabelle convinces the fisher to give her the oysters. That small interaction, in my mind, said so much, but I guess you had a reason for deleting it.
The section about the thief also feels less natural than in your previous submission but again, I'm sure you had to find a balance between all our feedback.
You paint a vivid picture of your characters, who they are and where they stand in relationship to each other. I can sense a looming family drama revolving around the Arthur-guy and you've piqued my interest as to what happened in Noah's homeland. A powerful start!
Thank you for the great read!
Rae
Thank you for the feedback. I thought the oyster selling part was more slow-paced and less important than the thief, as it foreshadow some scenes later so I made the choice to cut it, but I see it wasn't such a good idea. I'll see what I can do in the last version.
DeleteHi Amelia,
ReplyDeleteI can definitely see you've smoothed the language and added some great detail. I have some further comments on how you could make the narrative even more engaging. Please see below. Hope this is of use! Can't wait to read the pitch and the revised pages.
I suggest:
Rephrasing "Annabelle’s mother covered her dainty nose with one hand." for better flow: "Annabelle’s mother made a great show of covering her dainty nose with one hand."
Reconsider using word "struggled" in the second paragraph as it has negative connotation while your're characterising Annabelle as enjoying herself in the breeze.
I suggest rephrasing "She insisted to take the long detour by the beach," to "She insisted they took the long detour by the beach."
"The port was busy, like every Friday morning, but unlike her mother’s elegant clothing, Annabelle’s simple blouse and pants blended in well with the crowd." - I'd suggest replacing "but" with "and"
This bit doesn't read well and its structure is a bit awkward: "I must handle myself what those incapable servants are paid for..". No suggestion here, but have a think.
"Her fist hurt but she tried not to let it show, reminding herself to check it later." - I suggest deleting "reminding herself to check it later." to make the sentence snappier.
"...two officers approached, their pistol raised" - should this be pistols (plural), and also I suggest dropping "their", so it's just "two officers approached, pistols raised"
Re "Annabelle sighed, letting the waves splash bursts of cool water on her heated skin." - are the waves as high as a person? The way it's worded made me imagine Annabelle's face being splashed by a giant wave.Maybe make her kneel on the shore and reach for the water, or something?
"Even if she wanted to forget, her mother was a talking calendar." - for the sake of a snappier ending, I'd split this into two sentences and rephrase the first part of it. So it'd be: "As if she could ever forget. Her mother was a talking calendar." Or something like that.
Re: "“Lieutenant Jensen.” Governor Heatley’s voice was calm but firm.
Crap."
I'd delete "crap" as it sticks out and I'm not sure why would Noah react that way at first to a simple command.
Re "And Noah who thought times were getting easier. " -maybe better something like "And just when Noah thought times were getting easier. " Otherwise, it reads like an incomplete sentence.
Instead of "This was unexpected." can you show us some of Noah's reactions? Does his body relax as he releases his tension? Does his heartbeat calm a little not that he knows he';s not in trouble? It;s good to alternate between telling and showing and now is the good time to show.
Overall, great work!
Katya
Thank you for the feedback. I'm sorry for the weird phrasing as I'm not a native english speaker and I didn't have the time to show the revised version to one of my CP before submitting.
DeleteA special thank for the suggestions to make it better.
Hello again!
ReplyDeleteWonderful, as always. I love your voice and the idea of the story in general. I feel like I'd read this book if it were on the shelf in the library. It just sounds like something I'd like!
"She insisted to take the long detour by the beach, knowing her mother would prefer sand over mud." - Maybe "Annabelle insisted..." at first I wasn't sure who insisted until the second part of the sentence.
I need you here with me because you know how to talk to these people.” - If she doesn't want her daughter in this environment is there a reason she specifically needs her daughter to talk to the wharf people and not a servant or gentleman of some sort?
"Their green uniforms were pristine, probably because they had been doing nothing all day." - I like this sentence.
“Don’t wait for me, I’ll stick around here a little while longer.” Her mother turned to the sea and nodded. “Don’t stay too long. You must not be late for your dinner date with Arthur tonight, remember?” - If her mother wants to her to be a proper lady I feel like she might be a little upset that her daughter wants to stay at the wharf alone. Might be a good opportunity to show more of mom's personality,butting heads w/daughter.
"He never planned to get higher in ranks but if Governor Heatley was pleased with his hard work, then Noah was." - needs a "too" at the end.
Crap. - The word itself has been discussed already, but I'm wondering about the intent. Is he saying crap because he was startled or because he is being given an order? I feel like the more natural reason would be startled. if so, maybe make him have a physical reaction, like jumping or twitching or something.
mahogany - This is just a personal opinion, and I have no idea if it's valid at all - Because of the "It's Mahogany" Hunger Games meme I tend to steer clear of this wood, just because it pulls me out of the story I'm reading to Hunger Games. It could totally just be me, so take that with a grain of salt. :)
thanks for your feedback. I laughed at your comment about the mahogany. I remember the scene in the HG but I had no idea the use of this wood was getting cliché. I'll change it.
DeleteThanks again!
Hi Amelia,
ReplyDeleteYou’ve managed to focus the two scenes, I got a much clearer picture in my mind of the characters and their surroundings. Great revision!
I have a logical issue, which could be just subjective: her mom explains that she needs Annabelle to help her “talk with these people”, which to me set up well the following exchange with the oyster salesman. But that exchange didn’t happen. Why did you cut it out? I understand if it wasn’t essential and you wanted to tighten the scene, but then the motivation of her mom and Annabelle’s visit to the port weakens. Why are they there? Because they arrive, the thief interrupts their shopping, Annabelle catches him, and then her mom leaves her alone to spend some time at the shore. So they don’t do any shopping. Maybe add a sentence about “all the stalls they buy stuff from” before or after the thief, so that the trip to the port has motivation.
I also had another question here: I realize now that her mom is the First Lady, like the most superior woman in the country. Why is she doing her own shopping? Shouldn’t her servants do that? And souldn’t she have guards? If possible, include a short explanation like “this party was too important to leave the shopping to the cooks” (just a stupid example), just so the reader doesn’t get caught up in distracting questions. And about the guards: I think they should have at least a couple (better more) guards trailing after them, because this seems to be an average world when it comes to violence (there are thieves, weapons, wars), so the First Lady and her daughter shouldn’t walk around by themselves.
I find the initial pages intriguing, hopefully there’s a good love story between these two 😊
Lily
Thanks for your feedback. I'll try to make it clearer.
DeleteHi, Amelia,
ReplyDeleteI also am enjoying your engaging story. Good job on this revision. I like the setting, and can feel the sea breeze in my hair. :)
Regarding the mom's reaction to the "horrid smell": consider a prop that she might carry with her to combat the smells that she finds so offensive, a perfumed handkerchief, a lace fan, a lavender sachet, etc. The bonus might be that she can use the prop to emphasize her daintiness and show her mood. Just a suggestion. From your description, Mom's not a weak person, but she doesn't like messy stuff, seems to fight her environment.
For this line: "Women cried as a stocky hooded man bolted through the crowd." I imagine sobbing women. If that's not what you intend, consider "cried out, "shrieked", etc.
"Annabelle sighed, letting the waves splash bursts of cool water on her heated skin." Someone else mentioned this line. Is it the wave that splashes over her, or spray/mist from the breaking waves?
A few grammar-y things caught my attention.
"And Noah who thought times were getting easier." I think you can omit the word, who.
"Stained glasses windows"--Do you mean to say "stained glass windows?"
"Bright hazel eyes...the same as Anna."--The same as Anna's.
"This was unexpected." You could omit this telling line. The paragraph following that statement has all the info you need to convey, but will read stronger if you rearrange the 3 sentences.
I hope this helps.
Thank you for your feedback and grammar suggestions. This is really helpful.
ReplyDelete