Sunday, January 20, 2019

1st 5 Pages January Workshop - Passerotti Rev 2

13 comments:

  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You did a great job with your pitch. Rook looks after her little sister, seeking to protect her. The relationship between the two is endearing. You did a great job further describing this fantasy world, combining it with real-world scenes ( moth and hummingbird blossoms). You clarified Mom’s abscence, introducing one of the many challenges that awaits Rook.

      Delete
    2. Thank you! You're feedback and suggestions have been so helpful!

      Delete
  2. Hi Katie!

    I love what you did with the new first sentence! Though, flow-wise, the sentence is a bit too short to deliver a punch. It would be stronger and more immersive if you added something toward the end, maybe give the forest a name? "Warning whispered through the trees as Rook chased her younger sister across the Forest of [name]." Plus it would tell us immediately that this is fantasy.

    The sentence about the tree's murmurs felt off, I didn't immediately make the connection with the whispered warnings mentioned earlier. The line with Mareah "couldn't hear" is a POV break, as there is no way Rook would know that. I suggest you trim down that paragraph. I feel like we got a better sense of urgency in the last revision.

    That said, everything else flows nicely and I'm intrigued by the premise of your pitch! I'm getting Sleeping Beauty vibes. I love that Rook is the one doing the saving! My suggestion for your pitch is to keep the focus on one main character, and build the stakes and their goals around them. I don't know how many POVs you have, but the last paragraph is told through Finian's POV (while the rest of the pitch made it seem like it was Rook's), which made me wonder if he was the MC after all since his decision is the one that'll alter the story? Maybe you could reword that paragraph to make Finian the "villain" or the one thing that can stop Rook from getting what she wants. Good luck!

    It was nice seeing your progression through the weeks! You did amazing revisions, congrats! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. ugh! Thank you-- I will need to work on rephrasing the "Unlike Rook..." bit, it's not meant as a POV slip, its meant as knowledge the Rook already has because she knows her sister can't hear the trees. Do you think if I changed it to something along the lines of "Rook knew he sister couldn't hear the trees." that it would work better?

      Thank you so much for your suggestions and help! <3

      Delete
  3. Ooh, I like this story! Okay, starting with the pitch: In the first paragraph, I'm wondering if you could write your explanation of soulkin into the last sentence of that paragraph; incorporate it within to create more conflict. I only say this because leaving it the way it is takes me out of your blurb/story, which is good. Although I loved learning more about the motivations of your other characters, I think including their needs/wants/conflicts so specific within the blurb makes it confusing; there's too much information. Try barring the blurb down to - the MC (character), what she wants (goal), and what's standing in her way (conflict). Even if you mention 'those she recruits to help her', keep it simple. We don't need to know all about them yet. What you want is to give just enough to make us want to read more.

    Revision:
    I noticed your comment above about 'Unlike Rook...'. That information doesn't really fit where you have it. What if you 'showed' the reader this information with a brief roll of the eyes (bad example, but something) from Rook out of frustration that her sister can't hear the warning whispers like she can. Or you could also simply insert something like "... slipped away ...unable to hear the murmured caution from the trees like Rook." This would also add tension because the reader would feel like the character is in danger. And for some reason, I still don't like the use of the word adult. Maybe say she feels like the adult??? With this being a fantasy, that term could refer to lots of things.

    Minor: the paragraph at the end where Mareah giggles at seeing the moth - I think leaving the giggling out makes the sentence more powerful. Other than what I've mentioned, I've really enjoyed your story. Thank you for sharing it with us!

    Sheri~

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much for your help througout the workshop, I've really appreciated. I will keep working on that bit about Rook being able to hear the trees vs her sister not hearing them.

      And I'll work to streamline my pitch. The novel has 3 POVs so I'm trying to balance that out with keeping the overall focus on Rook since she's the main-MC. *ugh* Thank again, my first pages have definitely grown over these past weeks!

      Delete
  4. Hi Katie,

    Great job on the revisions! I think your opening does a great job at introducing us to the main character, the story world, and initial conflict.

    The Pitch:
    I agree with the above comments that I got confused about the focus on Finian in the last paragraph. I'm not sure exactly how to write a pitch with three POV's but that felt jarring to me.

    The Revision:
    The first few paragraphs have a lot more info now, but I think you can iron them out a little more to avoid confusion. Also, I don't know that this part is overly important, but I still feel like Rook is talking to Mareah when she says "you cheated." The only clue is that she flicks her gaze between Mareah and the tree, but that doesn't mean she is talking to the tree if that makes sense. Just a minor addition like, "she said to tree" would help clear that up!

    Great job on tightening this up!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much for your feedback! It's definitely helped me make my first few pages stronger <3

      Delete
  5. I thought your last revision was pristine, but this is better. I like the nuance that Rook is not tapped into the trees and can't abide by their warning. Your writing is so lyrical..."words gathered" and "steal away wonder." It is so very powerful. It reminds me of Pat Conroy. I was mesmerized by his sentences, yet he continued to move his story along.
    Thanks, Jeannie Lambert

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! It's been wonderful getting to work with you, thank you you for your help over these past weeks.

      Delete
  6. This is Erin posting for Amy:


    Hiya Katie,

    You have done such thorough revisions! You are a strong world-builder and make good use of concrete details (thick leather gloves, mottled bark, pale blue blooms, the glass vial, that wonderful slender leg and fuzzy antennae!). I have a much greater understanding/sense of this world right off the bat. Nicely done.

    I feel like I have a far greater sense of who Rook is – specifically her ability to hear the trees – it’s really great.

    Now I’d ask you to look at your text and to use that old writing school advice, “kill your darlings.” There’s also some quote somewhere (that I couldn’t find – maybe Nabokov?) about the author not weeping in the text so that the reader may weep? I’m massacring that, I’m sure but what I mean is look out for overwriting – for areas where the words are instructing the reader to feel rather then evoking feeling. An example:

    “But Mareah’s laughter, luminous and contagious, made her ignore the counsel of the trees.”

    We already heard Mareah’s “echoing laugh” the text here could simply read “But Mareah’s laughter made her ignore the counsel of the trees,” and then we feel it with Rook – because we’re not told it’s “luminous and contagious” it somehow becomes more luminous and contagious. The text continues, “The bud of tension nestled in Rook’s heart unfurled and a smile stole across her lips.”

    To my ear this is a little overwritten/overwrought. Also, does tension turn into something flowering? I think the reader sees Rook’s transformation well in her actions – she ignores her better sense and smiles at her sister’s fun.


    When you watch out for instances like this, where the details are more florid and baroque than the situation calls for, your text becomes more spare and then, when the details are necessary, world-building (or suspense-building, or adventure- or love-, or, or, or…) then those details, the necessary ones, really pop - musical and imagistic words like “snakeroot and hummingbird blossoms” resonate and offer their richness to your story.


    Your writing flows well and the pitch sounds great – I was a little confused by the last paragraph because it seems like it reads as if the story shifts to being Finian’s more than Rook’s? Not sure if I’m misunderstanding that part or not.


    Great work – and good luck with the book!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much! I'll work on getting in there and deleting all the superfluous words to make the pages stronger. I've really appreciated your insight and help over the course of this workshop. Thanks!

      Delete