Name: Mary Johnson
Genre: Middle Grade (dark fantasy)
Title: The Forest of
Beating Hearts
CHAPTER ONE
Snow swirls through
beams of golden moonlight. The market square is deserted, silent and asleep
like the rest of Iore City. Even the clock tower is draped in a blanket of
shadow and frost. Every now and then something screams from beyond the Wall,
but nobody is around to listen. The people of Iore are unconscious in their
beds and the city dreams with them.
Except for me and Dana,
of course.
Dana stands underneath a
gas lamp, arms wrapped around her shoulders. She reaches a gloved hand towards
the light. “I swear,” she says, “it ain’t never been this cold before. My
fingers are icicles.”
I grab the tattered
edges of her cloak and pull her away. “Stick to the shadows, remember? Do you
want to be seen?”
It seems a silly thing
to ask. If not for the snowfall, Iore City could be frozen in time. No windows
glow with candlelight. No chimneys exhale smoke. If I didn’t know that guards
prowl the streets, I would believe we were the only people in the world. But
we’re not. And since nobody is supposed to be awake after dark, we can’t get
caught.
Dana pouts. Blonde hair
sticks out at funny angles underneath her hood. She cut it with a paring blade
yesterday after it got too tangled, but she’s no hairdresser. Most of it barely
brushes her chin, though a few wild strands hang to her shoulders.
“You’re staring at my
hair again,” she says. “Cripes, Nairi, tell the truth already. Is it bad or
not?”
“I told you a million
times,” I say. “You look smashing.”
Dana laughs.
“Liar.”
I shush her but I have
to stifle a giggle too. Honestly, it’s a wonder we haven’t been caught already.
If Papa was here, he’d keep things good and serious. Now it’s down to me. Dana
is my best friend, but she’s a bad influence when it comes to acting
sensible.
“Let’s go,” I say. We
slink around the edge of the market square, past the closed-up haberdasher’s
and sweet shops. Across the square sits the Crystal Pavilion, with its spires
stretching upwards to pierce the sky and stain-glass windows casting rainbow
shadows on the paths below. All the other buildings in Iore are made of
filigreed black stone. It makes the glass walls of the Crystal Pavilion seem
even stranger in comparison.
Dana is focussed on the
shopfronts. “We could steal some warmer clothes,” she says. “Nobody’d know.
Some jackets, new scarves . . .”
I tug her onwards. “No,”
I say reluctantly. “We’re not that kind of thief.”
She groans but follows
me. As we leave the marketplace behind, the city seems to shrink around us.
Cobbled streets become narrower and rooftops zip together overhead, blocking
out the moonlight. I swear the streets switch places. No matter how hard I try
to memorize their routes, they seem to change every night. Sometimes, it feels
like the city is swallowing us, and I have to fight the urge to run back across
the Wall and into the forest we call home. Being eaten is kind of a fear of
mine.
“Here?” I ask. The house I’ve picked is
perfectly ordinary, three stories tall and carved with stone flowers. A window
on the top floor is open, drapes fluttering.
“Suits me.”
I nudge open the front
door and cringe when the hinges squeak. No lock, as usual. Dana shuts it behind
me. The house is swathed in darkness, and I trip over a bit of bunched-up
carpet as I head towards the staircase. Most houses have staircases in the
middle of their main rooms, so it isn’t hard to find, though I wish we could
have candles. The light would probably get us caught, but it’d stop me from
stubbing my toes all the time.
I try the first door I
see upstairs. It’s a bedroom. No wallpaper, just more black stone for walls and
ceilings. I shiver and my breath puffs into a cloud. It might be even colder
here than outside. Dana opens a chest of drawers and pulls out a
hand-mirror.
“Dany,” I say. “C’mon. I
told you, no messing with people’s stuff.”
“You’re no fun,” she
says, but she puts the mirror back.
I grit my teeth. It’s
not my fault Papa isn’t here and I have to pretend to be the adult. But we are
thirteen now, almost grown-ups ourselves. Now is not the time for playing
around. Sleeping Iorans never wake up, no matter how loud we are, but I don’t
want to make the guards angrier than we have to.
Sure enough, the boy in
the bed doesn’t even twitch as we search his room. I wish I could sleep so
soundly. But then, the people of Iore City aren’t human. Papa called them
automatons, but that isn’t quite right either. On the outside they look just
like us, fleshy and soft with hair that frizzes in the rain. The only thing
giving them away is a keyhole the size of a penny in the centre of their
chests—on the inside, they’re like wind-up toys. Without their keys, their
insides stop working and they shut down.
Imagine the damage if
someone decided to steal them.
“Found it,” Dana says.
She swipes a silver key from his bedside table. “They ain’t even trying to hide
‘em.”
“Because they’re
stupid,” I say. I’ve never been inside Iore during the daytime so I don’t know
for sure. But we have been stealing keys for almost two months now and they’ve
never tried locking their doors or hiding their keys. In fact, I’ve never come
across a door that actually has a lock or a shutter that has a bolt. They have
guards, but they’ve only managed to catch us once, back when we weren’t so
careful. And even then, escape was easy.
See, the forest where we
live is pretty dangerous. When Papa, Dana, and I stumbled across Iore City, we
thought we might finally be able to live in proper houses and have proper
lives. But the Iorans don’t want us here. We are from the forest beyond the
Wall. We aren’t Ioran. So to them, we are monsters.
Our plan is simple.
Steal the keys. Stop their hearts. And we won’t give any of them back until the
Iorans promise to let us stay. It doesn’t matter if they like us or not—it’s a
million times safer within the Wall than beyond it.
Dana ties the key to a
ribbon around her waist. Then we hop out of the window and climb down to the
street.
“Onward?” Dana grins
crookedly.
“Onward,” I
agree.
We run across the cobbles, not bothering about
which way. The more random we are, the harder it will be for guards to catch
us. Papa always said there’s nothing more dangerous than being predictable. We
climb up drainpipes, duck under arches, hurry past statues of angels and
gryphons and hooded figures, collecting keys whenever we feel like it. Although
we see no guards, I keep checking over my shoulder. I get the feeling the city
itself is watching us.
Loving the premise. The world is dark and strange. The prose is detailed and lovely. However, the opening lines don't hook me. Consider starting with "we are the only ones who don't sleep in the city of Iore, for example, then go into that prose.
ReplyDeleteThat being said, I think you do a good job of stretching out the details. Don't let those details trail off and make the action slow down, though. Every now and then, it loses me. The snippets are interesting, but I think in opening pages the action needs to move forward a little quicker.
Maybe you could reveal some of the things, like the people of Iore being automotons in dialogue, without getting too expository. It would make an interesting exchange.
Speaking of expository, it does trail off towards the middle end that aren't weaved in as well. Some language could change there. Ex: "See, the forest we live in is pretty dangerous." I think you could stand to show that better.
It's definitely hard in the first few pages, but you got this :)
I really like what you have! It's an interesting and unique world, yet it feels complete. You have great descriptive details, and the characters feel real.
ReplyDeleteIn the beginning, you establish a sense of danger with the screams behind the wall and a fear of getting caught. That seems to let up just a bit as the section moves on. For example, there never seems to be a chance that they'll be caught when they steal the key from the boy. What if Dana make a loud noise (drops the key or something), and there's kind of a heart-stopping moment? This kind of goes along with what James says above. I think the pace if pretty good, but it's actually that sense of danger letting up that makes it feel like it's slowed.
Just a couple small fixes!
Hi Mary
ReplyDeleteI love this world you are creating - it is creepy and dark and beautiful!
The initial paragraph was beautiful and haunting with the screams from beyond the wall, but then the tension drops as the girls discuss Dana's hair. It feels like maybe they aren't in any real danger, which loses more tension.
We also don't find out that they are here to steal until about halfway through the first five pages. Should this possibly come out earlier to hook us in/keep the tension up? Up to that point, it's just two girls sneaking around, but we don't really know why or what the conflict/risk is.
I love the automatons who live in Iore and I have so many questions about them and their keys - which is great! But maybe I need a little bit more reason behind why they are stealing keys - are they 'killing' the Iorians, or do they come back when the keys are returned? Do they know?
If, as far as they know, they are killing them, that seems a little over the top and probably not going to make the Iorians willing to let them live with them! I just couldn't quite follow the reasoning on that point. (Of course, this may be on page 6!)
Just my thoughts, but hopefully something useful in there for you.
Best
Becky
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHi Mary! Great start. I really love the idea of wind-up toy people and the world you've built. Great mood, love the idea of the cold and the dark punctuated by the moonlight and the Crystal Pavilion. Reminds me of Kingdom Hearts!
ReplyDeleteI agree with the other comments so far - feels like your first paragraph is a warm-up paragraph. Starting with "The people of Iore are unconscious" will put us right into the situation and a hook: Why are Nairi and Dana the only ones who aren't sleeping? etc. Then move into the atmosphere as they continue on their way, in a more organic way.
Also agree that the tension is lost when we find out that there's not really any chance of the two getting caught. I like the idea that something could happen that could throw off their plans -- maybe a "That's never happened before!" moment that causes the characters to act on their feet.
One of my favorite things was the voice -- I love "it ain't never been this cold before" -- so I would love to see this pervade the first person narrative even further. There are some places where Nairi drops out of it. Example:
But we are thirteen now, almost grown-ups ourselves. Now is not the time for playing around.
This might read more in character if it said:
But we're thirteen now. Almost grown-ups. Now's not the time for playing around.
I'm also a little dubious that stealing the keys is going to win our characters a place to live. Is Nairi's pop negotiating with someone inside Iore? How do the authorities who might be able to give Nairi what she wants even know it's her and her allies doing the stealing? How do they expect that it's going to work?
Looking forward to reading the next round!
Yours,
Joe
P.S. I accidentally commented earlier and then deleted my comment when I was trying to edit it... so I'm just replying to the old one with the updated comment. Yay the internet!
Hi Mary!
ReplyDeleteThis is an interesting story! Not only have you built a unique and darkly fascinating world, but you do a fantastic job showing the two girls' relationship. I love how they work well together, look out for each other, and even play around a bit despite the serious mission they are on together. I also like the hints your dropped about their father not being in the picture. It makes me want to know if he's dead, gone, or if I will get to meet him later on in the story.
It's an original premise, but I have to echo what others have said about building tension. Maybe if you had something happen, like a trap or an alarm sounds right after Nairi thinks "But we have been stealing keys for almost two months now and they’ve never tried locking their doors or hiding their keys." I think it would be so dramatic to lull the reader into a false sense of security along with the MC and then POW! Hit us with the unexpected. Let us see your characters react to that. It could potentially allow for so much world building and characterization, and I don't think you want to miss out on that in the first five pages.
Overall your writing it lovely and your plot is original. I'm excited to see where you go from here!
Mary,
ReplyDeleteThanks for submitting your pages. Wow. You are a writer. You’ve got a great sense of rhythm and pacing which is one of the hardest things to master. I really like this. It feels original. The idea of automaton-type beings that have a key inside of them is very intriguing.
I was a little thrown by the use of “ain’t.” Somewhere else Nairi says “smashing” and that makes me think of Brits. Ain’t feels a little to American and contemporary for this world you’ve created.
This is a very small thing, and it may just be me, but I want you to flop the opening sentence to become the second:
The market square is deserted, silent and asleep like the rest of Iore City. Snow swirls through beams of golden moonlight. Even the clock tower is draped in a blanket of shadow and frost. Every now and then something screams from beyond the Wall, but nobody is around to listen. The people of Iore are unconscious in their beds and the city dreams with them.
While “Snow swirls through beams of golden moonlight” is beautiful, I feel that the next sentence is much more inviting as an opening. Just a thought.
Every now and then something screams from beyond the Wall, but nobody is around to listen. The people of Iore are unconscious in their beds and the city dreams with them.
Beautiful.
I’m really curious as to the guards and why they’re not supposed to be out after dark. What kind of world is this? Interesting. Good stuff. Looking forward to seeing how it develops.
Hi Mary!
ReplyDeleteWow - these are really terrific opening pages. You write so descriptively, I can picture it in my head like a movie. It is so cold, and dark, and still - just fabulous! I also love this premise. As for stakes, I wonder if you could raise them. The Ions aren't so scary. I'm not worried at all about them getting caught, because you've told us they're dumb and it's easy to get away. There is also no sense of danger or suspense, because the reader isn't worried about them getting caught.
If you were to make the Ions more formidable, you'd really have a great start. Amp up the danger and the stakes, and you will hook the reader! You could also consider starting with the two girls in the forest, trying to get over the wall - show us what/who is trying to eat them!
Lastly, your prose is gorgeous. I love this bit:
Sometimes, it feels like the city is swallowing us, and I have to fight the urge to run back across the Wall and into the forest we call home. Being eaten is kind of a fear of mine.
But amp it up! Does she feel she's being watched? Is she worried there is more going on in the sleeping village than meets the eye? Does she start at each sound - swivel her head? Does it feel different tonight?
This is also lovely:
Snow swirls through beams of golden moonlight. The market square is deserted, silent and asleep like the rest of Iore City. Even the clock tower is draped in a blanket of shadow and frost. Every now and then something screams from beyond the Wall, but nobody is around to listen. The people of Iore are unconscious in their beds and the city dreams with them.
But the first few lines - gorgeous as they are - do not add to what I think you're trying to accomplish, which is to set this creepy dark stage. We don't get that until Every now and then.... and I'd like to hear it, not have her sum it up. Let's have a wail or scream startle them so they almost fall, let the reader be anxious! I'd suggest you go through and use the setting to add to the mystery/fantasy/scary element.
If you have any questions, shoot me an email or you can tag me in our facebook group. Good luck revising - I can't wait to read next week!!!!
Erin