Name: Danielle Roberts
Genre: Young Adult XXX
Grade: 12
Title: Without
There was something beautiful and terrifying about sleep all at once. The beautiful part was that for a while, you couldn’t worry or be afraid or think. It was like a veil—covering the difficulties faced once you opened your eyes. Sleep was a beautiful illusion of escape and darkness and peace. Only when that darkness was broken by consciousness did the terrifying reality begin. That was what sleep was like for me, and it was like that now as I opened my eyes to the white ceiling of my bedroom. The sounds of morning made their way through my open window and seeped beneath my door. Birds chirping, a pan sizzling, the loud voices of my parents, laughing about something that probably wasn’t even funny. I sat up and stretched, already preparing myself for the day to come. It was the same as always: Wake up. Act as if the serum worked. Go to sleep.
I got out of bed, not bothering to spread the blue sheets, and crossed the small space to my closet. I needed to buy a new journal today since I’d filled up my previous one the night before, cramming the last of my thoughts into the corner of the page. The thing about being a Resister was that I couldn't talk to anyone about it. Ever. I couldn't talk about how I felt like I was suffocating in a world of fake smiles and vacant eyes, how tiring it was pretending to be like them.
I had to keep it all in—all to myself, or else the AE's would haul me away in a second. So, a year ago I decided to start writing down how I felt. Keeping my emotions under a tight lid of fear for two years had begun to take its toll, and I'd go to bed every night wanting to scream into my pillow. Sometimes, when I was sure my parents were asleep and couldn't hear me, I did. But writing down the way I felt—how badly I wanted to punch something when I was angry, or cry when I was sad—lifted the lid of fear just a little, letting out some steam. It kept me sane. Or, as sane as one could be in this world. I tugged off my plain white t-shirt and pulled a green tank top over my head before changing into a pair of jeans.
I looked up at my clock to check the time before remembering that it was broken. The minute and hour hand were stuck on 4, jerking in one place. I glanced out my window instead. The sun was up and shining brilliantly, and I guessed that it was after nine. I stuffed the clothes I’d slept in beneath my purple pillow and headed to the bathroom. The red oak wood floor creaked beneath my feet as I stepped out into the hall and shut the bathroom door.I flicked on the light, illuminating the yellow shower curtain and peach towels and detangler spray bottles cluttered around the sink.I had the most difficult hair to deal with in my family. My dad’s great grandfather was from Scotland, and my mom’s grandmother was from southwestern Europe. Somehow, I ended up with curly roots and unruly wavy tips that came down past my back. Our old radio in the kitchen was on, spitting and sputtering out today’s latest news. I tried to block it out as I leaned over the bathroom sink and turned on the faucet, splashing cold water on my face.
The capture of two Resisters has taken place right outside of Berwyn this morning. AE’s who caught them were Jeffery Dole and Andrew Brown. We’re thankful to these two for helping make the world a better place. And we’re thankful for all of you as well! Keep sending in your tips and calling the AE hotline if you see or know a potential Resister. Remember, they disrupt the peace.
I shut off the faucet and looked up into the mirror, water dripping down my tanned face. Dad’s cheery voice carried down the hall. “Wow, the world is getting safer every day with these captures. Good thing, too.”
“Yes, good thing,” I muttered bitterly. My tired eyes stared back at me. They were the shiny caramel of a candy apple, but there was nothing sweet about them. I knew that in a few minutes I’d have to make them brighter. Awake. Happy.
I dried my face with a towel and brushed my teeth, all the while running through the mental list in my head as I did each morning for the past four years. No frowning, no faltering in my footsteps, no getting visibly angry or sad. Always have a faint smile lingering on my lips. I rinsed out my mouth and smiled at my reflection—the synthetic smile I’d perfected. I could hold it for a full five minutes without my cheeks burning. My eyes lit up, the exhaustion draining from them instantly. Good, I thought. I looked like one of them now. I stepped out of the bathroom, flicking off the light. On my way to the kitchen, I passed by the 20×30 picture of Simon Hugh Wells that hung on our white wall, and the black engraved letters that ran along the bottom half of the frame: “My goal was never to have a perfect world, but a peaceful one.”
His picture was beside the one of me as a three-year old toddler in our backyard. Wet grass stuck to my pink shorts, and my mud-stained hands waved to the camera. Many times, I thought about moving my picture so that it would be nowhere near that golden frame that displayed Simon’s round, smug face. His white-blond hair was slicked back, smooth like the surface of a lake, and those pale gray eyes seemed to follow my every move. My family wasn’t the only one with his face on our wall. Simon’s picture was hung up in almost every household and library I’d ever stepped foot in.
He was a hero, after all. “The scientist who cured the world.” It was what everyone said, what everyone believed. I used to think he was a hero. I used to get excited whenever I had to write a paper on him in school, eager to learn more about the inventor of Alacrisotium—the miracle serum that made you happy. I was eager to learn about the way it worked, how it slightly numbed the hypothalamus of your brain after being injected into the limbic system. It was exciting learning that the serum rapidly produced the neurochemicals GABA, Serotonin, and Oxycotin so that it was all anyone could feel. No more pain, no more anger, no more sadness.
And of course, I was intrigued at how Simon came up with the name. It was brilliant, after all. He took the Latin word for happiness—Alcris, and peace—Otium, and put them together. Genius. My opinion of Simon began to shift after I realized the serum hadn’t worked on me. After, at twelve years old, I had to train myself to act as if Alcrisotium had worked. Obsessively studying the behavior of those around me, pinching myself each time my smile slipped, terrified each time I stepped out of my room because I thought my parents would know.
Thanks for the chance to offer feedback. You've definitely piqued my interest with the beginning of your book. You were able to covey quite a bit of information in the first few pages of your story. It is an interesting premise that you've set up, and I wanted to read more to find out why the serum didn't work on your MC and if the effects can be reversed if the serum is stopped.
ReplyDeleteI like the way you have the MC journaling, especially as this could become problematic for her later if the journals are discovered. You've created a sense of danger/threat that lurks around her that really works in this genre.
So far, the MC is likeable and relatable. I might want to get a bit more details about the time frame we are in as far as the setting in these first five pages (how far into the future are we, if at all?) I'm reminded of the novel The Host where in some ways the world ran smoothly, but it was a "false utopia". These sorts of stories can really make me think about what price we are willing to pay for peace and harmony, so I think your story can be quite thought provoking.
I'm rooting for her to find some allies that will help ease her sense of isolation. Good start on the story. However, I would change up your first sentence a bit to make it stronger (the "all at once" didn't work for me, but that is just one opinion).
Thanks for this great feedback, I appreciate it :)
DeleteHi Danielle, I agree with most of what Melissa has to say here - I feel quite sympathetic towards your MC and her plight. One technicality for me is that she is obviously very sleep deprived because you mention her exhaustion but you open your story with her waking up - perhaps some allusion to the fact that although sleep was such a great release to her, it had never come easy?
ReplyDeleteThese scenarios where some 'hero' has come forward to save mankind through essentially supressing our basic nature are always fascinating. I question that if you remove conflict from our species how will you contain the population - it's a given that something dirty has to be going on in the background to keep the numbers under control - maybe a hint at that might give us some subtle understanding of our MC as a Resister and what that means - is she some sort of freedom fighter or is she a Resister because she is immune to the vaccinations - or both? It might help us if you spell this out a little more clearly.
Love the journals - I just know they are going to get her into so much trouble.
I like your MC and I feel for her having to live this life of lies and that her truth only exists in books which must remain hidden - there is something incredibly sad in that and I think your audience will really relate to it - there is something tragic these days about (particularly young adults) having to create a persona which has nothing to do with their reality and I think you have a vehicle for sending a very profound message here.
Gosh - I forgot to mention the most important thing here - I loved the clock. I love that it is stuck. I feel like everything is frozen - but life continues on.
ReplyDeleteThanks a lot! I'll take what you said into account :)
DeleteYou have an intriguing premise here, and I'm always a sucker for false utopias. But I think you can make your opening stronger and really get us to connect with her right away. One way you can do this is to focus on an inciting moment. You mention one here -- when she first got the serum at age 12 and her excitement for it was shattered. Why not start with that? Then we can see it first hand (not in flashback) and experience this disappointment with her. Maybe begin with her in line waiting for her injection, excited and thinking about everything she's learned about Simon. Maybe someone at the front of her line is also a Resister, and they immediately freak out, and the guards drag the kid away kicking and screaming. She's confused, then BOOM -- she gets her injection and nothing happens to her either, but now she knows to fake it. Then we can meet up with her as an older teen and see how she's adjusted to her condition.
ReplyDeleteVery Interesting, I like your suggestions. Thank you for the feedback!
DeleteHi Danielle, Thanks so much for being a part of the workshop this month. It’s great to have you with us!
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed these pages. The tone has a longing to it that fits with the character you are developing and the story you are setting up to tell. I do think you need to know what genre this is. Perhaps you haven’t put dystopian because that is currently given a lot of flack as being “done”. But even without labeling it as such, it will be clear to those who read it so say it proud! Nothing is “done” if the story is fantastic. Dystopians still sell—they just have some new twist here or there to break the mold. But this might also be full on science fiction? You need to know what your genre is to know where you story fits in the market.
Anyway, onto the pages!
While I don’t mind your first paragraph, and there is much great stuff in here—love the note about her parents laughing about something that probably isn’t funny—nice way to show the subtle effects of the serum this early on—, I think you could have a stronger opening line. I think your first line could definitely be in that paragraph but it just needs to be amped up and honed. I like the last line being unexpected.
Usually, we are told not to start with a character waking up and showering and getting dressed. These things are too “mundane” and we want to get to the action of the story as opposed to these things that everyone does. Now, I’ve written about this before—and my own character wakes up in chapter 1—so clearly I think rules are made to be broken. Here since you are showing your character is different and that she has to put on a face that isn’t hers, there’s a reason for showing her morning routine. However, in that case, then maybe you want to play up that morning routine more. Infuse more of what you have in that paragraph where she puts on her fake smile throughout all the things she does before then. Show us how she covers who she really is in every action. Or cut down on these actions until you get to the mirror as that’s the one that is most important and the purpose of showing us her morning routine.
I do think we need a sense of why this story starts today—not tomorrow, not yesterday. Is it the radio announcement she hears? Will those two resisters mean something? Does she know them? If that is not the reason this story starts today, you need to figure out why you are starting here. If it is the reason, maybe play with it even more. Let that be what wakes her? That’s the reality she is faced with?
ReplyDeleteIt could be cool to have her going through her morning routine hearing snippets of the radio. So we see her transitioning from who she was into who she is supposed to be while this radio report plays in the background. It is a great way to give us a bit more information about this world too. (And be sure to put the news report in italics or quotes if italics don’t show up here so we see that it’s not narrative text.)
For the first paragraph (and for all your writing) think about trimming down the extra words and being as efficient as you can. Be brutal in what you give us and make sure the extra is stripped out. For example, your first paragraph gives us multiple ways to describe how sleep is beautiful. Pick one. One will have more impact as it will be the focus and so then it stands out.
Great job here and excited to read the revision.
Oops, I deleted the comment due to a typo and accidentally responded to that one instead of yours. So here it is again haha:
DeleteThank you Lori, this is great feedback. I appreciate it!
I was unaware of the "no morning rule routine" but as you said, some rules are routine" but as you said, some rules are meant to be broken. I like your idea of my MC hearing the radio as she gets ready (I had the broadcast in italics, not knowing it wouldn't show here, but I'll be sure to include quotations). I'm not quite sure what you mean about why the story starts today. Do you mean why it's not a flashback or her remembering the day before ? I'll definitely work on the first sentence snd cutting out unessaesary words. Thanks !
PS- this is a dystopia, it just didn't register that dystopia was in a different category than young adult
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThank you Lori, this is great feedback. I appreciate it!
DeleteI was unaware of the "no morning rule routine" but as you said, some rules are routine" but as you said, some rules are meant to be broken. I like your idea of my MC hearing the radio as she gets ready (I had the broadcast in italics, not knowing it wouldn't show here, but I'll be sure to include quotations). I'm not quite sure what you mean about why the story starts today. Do you mean why it's not a flashback or her remembering the day before ? I'll definitely work on the first sentence snd cutting out unessaesary words. Thanks !
PS- this is a dystopia, it just didn't register that dystopia was in a different category than young adult
Hi Danielle, what I mean about why story starts today is this: Consider the Hunger Games. We enter that world on that day why? Because it's the day of the reaping. Something is happening that day (called the inciting incident) and that's what makes that day special. We don't want to follow Katniss the day before the reaping because all we will see is her eating, walking, sleeping, etc. It's her life, yes, but the inciting incident hasn't happened yet--the thing that jumpstarts the novel. Books start on the day "something happens". It can be a reaping, a letter arriving that changes things, parents telling their kids they are getting a divorce, a new neighbor moving in--all those things can be incident incident--things that kick off the story in the novel. That's why we enter the story on that day. Does this make sense?
DeleteAnd genre is a bit misleading at times. Technically young adult is more the category and genre is horror, contemporary, science fiction, dystopian, Western, etc.! ;)
DeleteOh! Okay, I see what you mean now, Lori. Thanks! There is an event that kick-starts the story, but it's the next day. I can move it to this day instead, but would that mean I had to hint or mention the event ?
DeleteHello, I really enjoyed reading your first five pages. It had a definite dystopian feel which I really liked. I agree with Erin about going back to the initial reaction to the serum not working. I think it would really set the tone of the book and tell a lot about your character.
ReplyDeleteHello, I really enjoyed reading your first five pages. It had a definite dystopian feel which I really liked. I agree with Erin about going back to the initial reaction to the serum not working. I think it would really set the tone of the book and tell a lot about your character.
ReplyDeleteHello Valarie, thanks a lot for this feedback. Originally, the story did begin with my MC finding out the serum didn't work, but it seemed too cliche and so I re-wrote the beginning.
DeleteHi Danielle, so sorry to be getting on here late this week! I have nothing really new to add to the wonderful comments you've received so far - I totally agree with everything Lori Goldstein said about your opening, trimming, the question of what is so different about today, this moment, and the inciting incident? etc.
ReplyDeleteI also really liked the suggestion made above about showing the scene of your MC receiving the serum and it not working. That scene would give the reader immediate tension and a chance to show off your world with cool details and people and action and dialogue. Go back and look at the 5 pages - there is only 1 paragraph with dialogue in all of that text. In 5 pages your reader's eyes could glaze over. They want to see some action, even though it might be small, and dialogue and tension right away. Hiding the fact that the serum doesn't work on her really adds a ton of tension to everything your MC does every single moment of every single day. Really maintain that, it's great.
You DO have some very beautiful writing and I was drawn in immediately to this world, the prose is so smooth as well as haunting in places. You're obviously a very talented writer. Now it's just a matter of rearranging the plot pieces.
Can't wait for the revision!
~Kimberley
Hello Kimberley :) Thank you for this awesome feedback, I'll really try to open the story with a different scene that shows the serum not working and shows more of the world this time. Thanks for the compliment as well, it means a lot! :)
Delete