Monday, January 7, 2013

1st 5 Pages January Workshop - Goldstein

Name: Lori A. Goldstein
Genre: Young Adult Contemporary Fantasy
Title: BECOMING JINN


A chisel, a hammer, a wrench. A sander, a drill, a power saw. A laser, a heat gun, a flaming torch. Nothing cuts through the bangle. Nothing I conjure even makes a scratch.

I had to try. But the silver bangle encircling my wrist can’t be removed. Shielded by magic, the bangle is what releases the powers coursing through my veins. It’s like being infected by a virus. And it’s going to kill me. I know it.

I slam my newly acquired accessory against my bedroom closet leaving a rounded indent on the wood door. The pristine, gleaming metal of the bangle mocks me. For the rest of my life, I’ll go where I’m told, perform on command, and do it all without question.

Screw that.

I race into my bathroom.

Click. Click. Click.

I turn on the faucet and watch with satisfaction as the red tips of the long, manicured nails that replaced my formerly short, round ones overnight swirl around the basin and disappear down the drain.

Snip. Snip. Snip.

A blanket of dark espresso hair surrounds my feet. I’ve sheared off the three inches that are new since yesterday and then some. The color, which morphed from mouse to mink while I slept, is an exact match for my mother’s. It can stay. The sheen helps the chin-length bob I’ve given myself look halfway decent.

Seriously, how was I supposed to explain the sudden change in length? I’m not the type of girl to get hair extensions. I don’t want people to think I’m the type of girl who would get hair extensions.

I splash water on my face and can feel the length of my eyelashes. Leaning over the vanity, I peer into the glass and widen my eyes. I used to be able to get away with calling them hazel, flecked with gold. They are now simply gold. Amber. The color is an exact match not only for the color of my mother’s eyes but for the color of all Jinn’s eyes. And I can’t have that.

Lucky for me, my learning curve with this conjuring thing has been fast. One crooked wrench, one inoperable lighter, and one unrecognizable reciprocating saw preceded the plethora of tools turning my bedroom into a hardware store. And in all fairness, the mangled saw is more because I have no idea what a reciprocating saw actually looks like.

Just as I did when conjuring each tool, I steady my breathing, tune my ears to the beat of my heart, which pumps my Jinn blood at a rate closer to that of hummingbirds than humans, and close my eyes. I picture a pair of transparent contacts tinted dark brown.

An icy tingle snakes through my body. I shiver. My body craves heat. In all the ways I take after my mother — in all the ways I take after all Jinn — an intolerance for cold is the one that bothers me the least.

I concentrate until a bead of sweat forms on my upper lip and the slimy lenses float in a sea of saline in the palm of my hand.

I’m not supposed to be enjoying this. I know what unleashing my powers means. But for this second, alone with this magically enhanced version of myself staring back at me, I allow myself to be impressed.

Though my Jinn ancestry means magic has always been inside me, the rules don’t allow me to begin drawing upon it until the day I turn sixteen. The day I receive my silver bangle. The day I officially become a genie. Today.

Or more accurately, last night. As I set the contacts down, the bangle clanks against the bathroom counter. It was smart of my mother to secure it in the middle of the night while I was asleep, unable to protest.

When I woke up this morning, she was sitting next to me, a tentative smile on her face.

“Happy Birthday, kiddo,” she said, lifting me off the mattress and wrapping her arms around my torso, which I had yet to notice had elongated during the night.

I sensed the bangle even before the cool of the metal against my skin confirmed its presence. When my eyes adjusted to the sunlit room, my heart found its way to my throat.

I knew this was coming. I grew up knowing this was coming. But still, a part of me believed something would stop it. Maybe my mother would finally realize I was serious. I’ve been begging her to find a way around me having to become a genie since I was old enough to understand what the word “destiny” meant. Maybe the Afrit, our ruling class, would decide my well-honed lack of enthusiasm was an insult to the long line of Jinn from which I descend. Maybe they’d take one look at me and realize for the first time in Jinn history, powers should skip a generation.

The thick shackle masquerading as a piece of jewelry clamped around my wrist meant, despite my contempt for all things Jinn, everyone still wanted me to become one. Everyone but me.

Nothing could be more oxymoronic than the “happy” before my mother’s “birthday.” I pressed my tongue against the roof of my mouth and swallowed the lump in my throat.

I leaned first my pillow and then myself against the headboard and clutched the oval pendant around my neck. Through it resembles a locket, there’s no hinge on the silver medallion allowing it to open. The cursive “A” engraved on the front stands for the first letter of the name I share with the necklace’s original owner, my grandmother, whom I’ve never met. Having no family save for one’s mother is a side effect of being Jinn.

Like a security blanket, the false locket has always calmed me. I was so young when my mother first hooked the chain around my neck that I don’t remember it. But I’ve worn it every day of my life since.

I let go of the pendant, which seemed lighter in my hand than usual, and studied the bangle. Anger, disappointment, nerves, and an unexpected dose of fear fought to become my alpha emotion. My mother was holding her breath, waiting for my response. As cathartic as I’m sure the outburst she was expecting would have been, it wouldn’t have changed anything.

I simply wiggled my wrist at her. “Thanks for the present,” I said, imbuing my tone with sarcasm so heavy I hoped it would cover any shakiness in my voice.

“Figured it’d be better if it was quick,” she said, “like a Band-Aid.”

The bangle is nothing like a Band-Aid. It’s the opposite. Fast, slow, doesn’t matter. It’s not something you take off. Ever. I couldn’t have stopped the bangle from ensnaring my wrist along with the rest of me any more than I could have stopped all the ways my body was altered while my mind was unable to resist. Whether I was conscious or unconscious, my life was going to change. I was turning sixteen, after all.

Unlike the human world, sixteen is the age when Jinn become adults and our indentured servitude to the Afrit begins. The bangles stimulate our bodies to reach full maturity, which as an inherently attractive species, tends to make us, well, hot. I don’t think it’s actually a quid pro quo thing (and if it is, we Jinn must be the most shallow of species), but then again, I’m purposely ignorant of the inner workings of the Afrit.

18 comments:

  1. Opening: Made me curious. Eventually delivered on the promise.
    Strengths: Unique voice(I like the sarcasm of the MC), premise held my interest (I am intrigued at how she might get herself out of her predicament), just enough details, shows instead of tells, I can sympathize with the MC, some humor at times,
    Would the average reader stick with this? I think so, but I'd be a little careful with some word choices that sometimes sound like you're just trying to use more sophisticated language. Would this MC use THOSE words? Maybe yes. Maybe no. EX. imbuing
    "An icy tingle snakes through my body. I shiver. My body craves heat. In all the ways I take after my mother — in all the ways I take after all Jinn — an intolerance for cold is the one that bothers me the least." If her body is craving heat, it sounds like it bothers her more than she admits.
    Would I read more of this? Absolutely. My curiosity is piqued, and I have already invested some time/emotion into the MC.
    "Seriously, how was I supposed to explain the sudden change in length? I’m not the type of girl to get hair extensions. I don’t want people to think I’m the type of girl who would get hair extensions." I'd be curious how this genie even makes it back into a normal world where it even matters what she looks like at this point. I mean, since she's going to be working for the Afrit now. That's about all the nit picks I have. Good Luck!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like the premise: Genies living among us. I'm unsure, though -- are they a secret? It also threw me off a little when she runs to the bathroom -- the click. click. click. -- perhaps it wouldn't be so jarring if the sound effects came after the action. Paraphrasing: "I ripped off my nails. Click, click, click against the sink." I like the main character, she's relatable and likeable. Her sarcasm works. And lastly, trust your reader! "The thick shackle masquerading as a piece of jewelry clamped around my wrist meant, despite my contempt for all things Jinn, everyone still wanted me to become one. Everyone but me." The last sentence is a little repetitive. Based on her plethora of tools and her overall disgust with all things Jinn, we already know she doesn't want to become one. Overall, I think you've got a strong start! I would keep reading. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great topic! And I'm not just saying that because it's genies (my Djinn book comes out in April but is very different). I like the premise, and I'm getting a good sampling of her voice, but I feel like I need to be grounded in her normal life before this happens to her. I might be sleep deprived and have missed it, but I don't think I got her name! I like the world building you slip in right away, but I'd also like to see what her mother, a full blown Jinni has to do. How's this going to affect her life? Overall really liked it though!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Excited to read your Djinn book Lisa! I was wondering what you meant by "see what her mother...has to do."

      Also, to everyone, I had originally started the book with her alone, waking up to find the bangle around her wrist. She then has an interaction with her mother (which uses some of the wording of what's in this selection) where she makes her birthday cake float, her first use of magic. The cutting off her hair and trying to rebel by undoing her overnight makeover came a bit later after her mother gives her some lessons and they have a fight. (chapter 3) I changed that because a couple of people gave me that warning about never starting with someone waking up (though many books do). The idea was not to turn people off by starting that way. Hence the flashback that's in here. But I think the original way probably "grounded" you more in the world first. Any thoughts on starting with her waking up versus what I have now? Thanks!

      Delete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Lori--So excited to be Workshopping with you. Love the story so far--haven't read anything with a genie in it before. :o) But let's get down to work...

    *"I had to try. But the silver bangle encircling my wrist can’t be removed. RIGHT AFTER THESE TWO FIRST LINES I GOT A LITTLE CONFUSED--IN RETROSPECT, IT MAKES SENSE, BUT IN THE INITIAL READING I WASN'T SURE EXACTLY WHAT WAS GOING ON. I'M NOT SURE YOU NEED THIS INFORMATION RIGHT HERE. I'M ALREADY INTRIGUED. Shielded by magic, the bangle is what releases the powers coursing through my veins. It’s like being infected by a virus. And it’s going to kill me. I know it."

    *I don't think you need the CLICKS and SNIPS.


    *"I turn on the faucet and watch with satisfaction as the red tips of the long, manicured nails that replaced my formerly short, round ones overnight swirl around the basin and disappear down the drain. " THIS WAS ANOTHER INCIDENT WHERE IT MADE MORE SENSE ON THE SECOND READ THROUGH, BUT IT REALLY STOPPED ME IN MY TRACKS AT FIRST. I COULDN'T FIGURE OUT WHAT WAS GOING ON. I KEPT THINKING OF A PERSON ON THE RUN TRYING TO CHANGE THEIR APPEARANCE AND I WAS GETTING CAUGHT UP IN THAT FRAME OF REFERNCE. I THINK YOU CAN DROP OR REPHRASE TO MAKE CLEARER.

    *"A blanket of dark espresso hair surrounds my feet. I’ve sheared off the three inches that are new since yesterday and then some. The color, which morphed from mouse to mink while I slept, is an exact match for my mother’s. It can stay. The sheen helps the chin-length bob I’ve given myself look halfway decent. I LOVE THIS CONCEPT. IN ORDER TO MAKE IT CLEARER FOR THE READER, I WOULD SUGGEST MAKING THE CHIN-LENGTH BOB REFERENCE EARLIER TO GROUND THE READER. THEN TALK ABOUT HOW SHE WAS CUTTING IT OFF BECAUSE IT WAS GROWING SO FAST--MAGICALLY.

    ReplyDelete
  6. *POSING A QUESTION: (This may be cleared up as your story goes on, but I thought I'd pose questions that come to me in case it does become a wrinkle) She doesn't want certain people to detect her physical changes, but it seems like this happens to all the Jinn--how do they deal with it? Does she have a special relationship with people that the rest of her kind don't? What makes her concerned about fitting in and staying under the radar--something that doesn't seem to worry her mom?

    *POSING A QUESTION: I thought the reciprocating saw part was hysterical--but make sure you've clearly thought through the world building for that. For all the rest of her conjuring, she will have to have an equivalent amount of intimate knowledge about an item to conjure it. This could be a really fun element to the story, but you have to have clear rules for this so you don't get slipped up. How much does one have to know to conjure correctly? Is it just having a clear visual? Is it mechanics? Does this skill change with time and practice?

    *"I knew this was coming. I grew up knowing this was coming. But still, a part of me believed something would stop it. Maybe my mother would finally realize I was serious. I’ve been begging her to find a way around me having to become a genie since I was old enough to understand what the word “destiny” meant. Maybe the Afrit, our ruling class, would decide my well-honed lack of enthusiasm was an insult to the long line of Jinn from which I descend. Maybe they’d take one look at me and realize for the first time in Jinn history, powers should skip a generation. IT MIGHT BE NICE TO HAVE THE SLAVE REFERENCE EARLIER--HELPS THE READER TO KNOW WHY SHE THINKS OF THIS AS SUCH A NEGATIVE THING IN CONTRAST TO HAVING A MAGICAL POWER.

    *I loved the sarcasm and the interactions between her and her mom!

    ReplyDelete
  7. *"The bangle is nothing like a Band-Aid. It’s the opposite. Fast, slow, doesn’t matter. It’s not something you take off. Ever. I couldn’t have stopped the bangle from ensnaring my wrist along with the rest of me any more than I could have stopped all the ways my body was altered while my mind was unable to resist. THIS SEEMS CONTRADICTORY TO ME--HER BELIEVING SHE HAD NO HOPE AT ALL. IT SEEMS LIKE SHE SHOULD HAVE AT LEAST THOUGHT THERE WAS A SLIM CHANCE SHE COULD CHANGE HER DESTINY OR WHY FIGHT SO HARD TO AVOID IT? Whether I was conscious or unconscious, my life was going to change. I was turning sixteen, after all."

    *"Unlike the human world, sixteen is the age when Jinn become adults and our indentured servitude to the Afrit begins. The bangles stimulate our bodies to reach full maturity, which as an inherently attractive species, tends to make us, well, hot. ROTFL! LOVE THIS! I don’t think it’s actually a quid pro quo thing (and if it is, we Jinn must be the most shallow of species), but then again, I’m purposely ignorant of the inner workings of the Afrit."

    *You've left me very curious--it's obvious there is a lot more to come. Love the voice and the concept and I hope you find my first pass at your work helpful.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Just saw your comment about waking up and I have to say--I like her active and feisty. It suits her character.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Kimberly for your thoughtful comments. I really appreciate it. I do like the active start as well, but some felt they weren't grounded enough beforehand. Perhaps with some tweaking as suggested above, I can work on that a bit more. Thanks!

      Delete
  9. I bet you can come up with a great compromise!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks to all for your great comments. Question: Do you need more of why she doesn't like having to become a genie yet? Or is what you are getting in these first five pages enough? She's partly a teenager and rebellious, doesn't like to be told what to do, but there are also costs that come with being a Jinn (inability to form human relationships; Jinn fathers aren't allowed to live with their families) plus a circumstance in her childhood that makes her realize having magic doesn't fix everything. You will find all this out through the first three chapters. Is that okay or was anyone looking for more explanation here?

    Starting with action and all that info was too much to do in 5 pages so I erred on the side of action figuring you'd go along with the sprinkling of why this isn't her top choice.

    Thoughts welcome!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi Lori, I enjoyed your first five pages and really liked the title. As others have already noted, the genies premise is cool! The very first images were strong (chisel, hammer, wrench), but I wonder if you could cut one group out and include only two? Otherwise it starts to sound like someone is reciting a long list of words. But I could feel the MC’s frustration with the bangle and I definitely got caught up in her aggravation so the tension was there. I wonder if the paragraph “Though my Jinn ancestry…I officially become a genie.” could be moved up a bit earlier? For me that was the best and most interesting paragraph. I like the word “Jinn” but got confused in your very last paragraph because it almost sounded the writing was being switched to third person and we were being told about Jinn, whom I suddenly thought was the MC. I had to reread it to get that the MC was still talking. Regarding your question about addressing why she doesn’t desire to become a genie yet, I would say you could give us small hints that imply it, but you may not need to reveal it all just yet. Maybe she could vividly imagine the transformation and then, be completely disgusted with it? Something like that. Overall, nice job!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Hey, I really liked this and only had a few little things to mention.

    Firstly it's a fascinating intro – the only thing jilting me in the first two paragraphs is the repetition of bangle 3 times. Band… bracelet… maybe?

    I think you need a comma after closet for that to read correctly. And you probably don’t need ‘of the bangle’ since we know what you’re talking about. You don’t want the pace slowing in the intro from repetition.

    I like the characterization in the faucet line but it’s quite long. Can you break it up? I also love the rhythm in your writing, both in the first paragraph and the click/snip lines. :)

    Her conjuring the contacts was awesome, but I didn’t realise she’d actually done it until she put them down. The fact that they were in saline in her hand still sounded like part of a surreal vision to me. I obviously didn’t connect to the gold eyes problem straight away so if no-one else noticed, don’t worry about it, but if there’s any further confusion you might add something about her being about to/able to fix it when she says her learning curve had been quick.

    If she’d been asleep with the bangle then the cool of metal wouldn’t happen – unless it’s always cold.

    And that’s all my nitpicking – overall it’s a really intriguing concept and character. Good job! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Katherine! I appreciate your comments on the "bangle" references. Easy fixes there.

      There seems to be 50-50 on liking the click and snip lines and those being confused or want them gone. Guess that's always the way--all readers don't agree!

      Do those who haven't weighed in on liking the lines want to do so now? (They'd be in italics in the MS; didn't come through here. That may help.)

      As for the contacts, I had intended the "And I can't have that." to alert you to her wanting to disguise her new eye color. Originally I had. "Contacts!" after that then thought it was overkill, but maybe not.

      Thanks again!

      Delete
  13. Hi! What I meant was I'd like to see what's expected of of a Jinni through her mom. If she doesn't want that life, then she must be using her for a model, right? Just a good way to show. Also, I think you should not start with the waking up. But really think about whether you need a flashback vs. just a line here or there explaining. Can't wait to read the revision!

    ReplyDelete
  14. Hi Lori,

    Fantastic concept with intriguing worldbuilding and a very reaable character and voice. To avoid repeating what has already been said by others, I will simply say that I echo all the good things. This is a very strong start.

    Thoughts to ponder though:

    1) I'm not sure that you have us grounded in the present world sufficiently. This doesn't need to necessarily mean that we need to know all the details of her life, but at this point, I'm not sure we know anything about her. Who is she concerned will think she is the kind of girl who wears hair extensions? Humans? Does she go to a human school? Have a human best friend? Do her friends not know she is Jinn? Where does she live? Earth? Some Jinn place? We can't fully appreciate the trauma she is going through unless we know what she is fighting for as well as what she is fighting against.

    2) I'm not a huge fan of the flashback, but I love where you start the story. So ... Could you possibly consider having her in the bathroom and having her mother come in so that your mc can yell at her for doing this in her sleep? The mother can then explain her rationale, and you can get some of these things out in dialogue and direct conflict instead of narrative. You will then also have an opportunity to set up who she is getting dressed *normally* for and give us her mother's take on that.

    3) Out of the direct conflict above, you can help us understand the stakes more clearly? Is there any point to her trying to get the bangle off? Wouldn't someone just put it back on? Or would she run away? Where is she running from? To? Is the story question whether she can escape the bonds of being a Jinn? Or is the story question who she is bound to?

    Lisa Cron has a great post today on Writer Unboxed, and one of the things that I love about her writing advice is always the point about setting up your main story question as early as possible and then making sure that everything else pertains to how that outer quest forces your mc's inner change.

    Great beginning! I'm very much looking forward to seeing what you do with this!

    Best,

    Martina

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Martina for your nice comments and insights. Seems like the grounding is an issue for enough readers that I need to work on that. Unsure how exactly at the moment to start where I start *and* do that, but I'll be thinking hard about it. When I started with her waking up, I think you got that grounding unfortunately that you lose with this action. Perplexed but pondering...

      Delete